The Best Casual & Affordable Eats in Marco Island
Read article
The Best Seafood Restaurants in Marco Island
Discover the best seafood in Marco Island, from fresh Gulf-caught fish and stone crab claws to upscale waterfront dining and laid-back local favorites.
By
Kelly Carr
and
Scott Carr
Updated
Crabby Lady in Goodland
Marco Island is a seafood lover’s paradise, where the Gulf of Mexico delivers a daily bounty that defines the local culinary scene. Whether you are looking for elegant fine dining or a casual dockside grill, the island offers an authentic taste of the coast in every bite.
From the buttery sweetness of seasonal Stone Crab claws to expertly prepared Gulf Grouper and Red Snapper, Marco Island’s restaurants cater to every palate. This guide explores the must-visit spots for:
- Fresh Local Catches: The journey from boat to plate.
- Waterfront Dining: Enjoying your meal with a sunset view.
- Hidden Gems: The iconic spots locals keep to themselves.
Ready to find your new favorite meal? Here is our curated list of the best seafood restaurants in Marco Island.
View Map
Showing 8 results
4.6
912 Google reviews
Seafood, American
$$-$$$
Located in the historic fishing village of Goodland, Crabby Lady is a quintessential waterfront destination that captures the soul of "Old Florida." This relaxed, dockside staple is famous for its in-house preparations, ranging from creamy Blue Crab Dip and hand-breaded Grouper Bites to its celebrated seasonal Stone Crabs.
The menu balances coastal comfort with fresh, premium ingredients, featuring standouts like the Lobster BLT with lemon aioli and the Blackened Mahi topped with fruit salsa. By combining high-quality dishes like the Colossal Crab Salad with a welcoming, "come-as-you-are" vibe, Crabby Lady remains an essential landmark for anyone seeking an authentic taste of Southwest Florida.
Editor's Tip
A true highlight for local anglers is the "You Hook It, We Cook It" service, where the kitchen expertly prepares your own fresh catch.
4.6
1065 Google reviews
Seafood
$$-$$$
LeeBe Fish serves up an unapologetically simple yet exceptional seafood experience: local commercial-fishing boats catch most of the fish you’ll eat here, so everything arrives fresh from hook to plate. This no-frills spot is a favorite for fans of grilled or fried grouper, snapper, stone crab, shrimp baskets, homemade coleslaw and unbeatable value.
4.6
610 Google reviews
Seafood
$$$$
Fin Bistro has built a reputation as Marco Island’s premier fresh-fish restaurant since opening in 2012. Locally owned and passionately run, it offers a vibrant, relaxed island oasis where the focus is on showcasing the very best local and regional catches—prepared daily with creativity, precision, and flair.
4.6
1518 Google reviews
Seafood
$$-$$$
Nestled on the waterfront in Goodland’s historic fishing village, Little Bar has been a beloved local tradition for more than 45 years. The menu highlights fresh, local seafood and quality steaks, with signature items like stone crab claws, grouper, soft shell crab, and prime rib served in hearty portions.
Guests can settle in indoors, on the screened lanai, or out on lush waterside patios, all while soaking in the easygoing, Old Florida charm. With some of the best live entertainment on the island, a cozy bar, and a welcoming atmosphere, Little Bar continues to be a place where visitors and locals alike gather for great food, music, and memories.
Seafood, American
$$-$$$
Dolphin Tiki Bar & Grill serves up waterfront island vibes with cool drinks, fresh seafood and a lively, family-friendly atmosphere. Located tucked away but worth the find, the tiki-hut style bar and patio overlook marinas and pelicans as you settle in for grouper sandwiches, sushi rolls, Ahi tuna nachos or creative apps like fried brie with raspberry melba sauce.
Casual and comfortable, this spot excels at mixing value with view—happy hour specials, daily lunch specials and the kind of approach-friendly menu that keeps locals returning. Whether you arrive by boat or bike, it’s a laid-back option for lunch, dinner or drinks by the water.
4.5
1036 Google reviews
Seafood, American, Steakhouse
$$-$$$
Cocomo’s Grill invites you to slow down, unwind, and enjoy a laid-back island-themed dining experience where everything from seafood and steaks to pasta and sandwiches is served with generous portions and friendly service. With dishes like seared tuna nachos, coconut shrimp, jalapeño-crusted flounder, and their “U Hook It We Cook It” seafood option, the menu offers something for everyone.
With its vibrant patio atmosphere, relaxed bar scene and an emphasis on fun (plus an affordable, well-curated wine list), Cocomo’s Grill is a smart choice when you’re looking for a dependable casual meal that still delivers flavor and value.
4.4
2218 Google reviews
American
$$-$$$
Mango’s Dockside Bistro on Marco Island offers vibrant waterfront dining in a relaxed and welcoming setting. With panoramic views of the bay and marina at the Esplanade on Smokehouse Bay, it’s ideal for families, groups, or anyone wanting a taste of coastal Florida cuisine.
The menu highlights include fresh-catch seafood such as black grouper, jumbo scallops and lobster, alongside tropical-inspired dishes like their famous Key West Salad and island burrito bowls. The spacious outdoor patio, 750-gallon saltwater fish tank and full sushi bar enrich the ambiance, while the atmosphere stays friendly and family-oriented.
8
Sami's
4.5
1918 Google reviews
American, Italian, Pizza, Mediterranean, Global
$, $$-$$$
Sami’s brings a vibrant, family-friendly vibe to Marco Island with something for everyone—award-winning thin-crust pizza, gyro wraps, pasta classics, and coastal-leaning seafood options. Whether you’re grabbing a casual lunch, enjoying brunch with bottomless mimosas, or relaxing into laid-back dinner with live music, Sami’s offers a relaxed yet lively atmosphere that fits groups, families or solo visitors alike.
